Maths · Ages 14 and up

Cancelling: cross out factors, never added terms

1. See it

A fraction with letters, and the fraction you get by crossing out the repeated number. Pick numbers for x and y and see if the two have the same value. If they do not, crossing out was wrong.

3 + x3 + y ≠ xy as written = 7/8 after crossing out = 4/5 with x = 4 and y = 5: different values

2. Try it

(3 + x) / (3 + y): With x = 4 and y = 5: as written it equals 7/8, and the crossed-out version x / y = 4/5. They are different, so crossing out here is WRONG. Here the 3 is ADDED to x. It is a term, not a factor of the top. You may only cross out a number that multiplies everything on the top and everything on the bottom. The fraction cannot be made simpler by crossing out. Its top and bottom have no common factor to remove.

x and y are whole numbers from 1 to 9 so you can check by hand. A check with a few numbers can show that a step is wrong. It does not prove that a step is right, but for the fractions here the reasons are given.

3. Say it simply

  • To cancel, divide the top and the bottom by the same number. That is allowed because the value of the fraction does not change.
  • The number must be a factor of the WHOLE top and of the WHOLE bottom. A factor is something that multiplies everything, like the 3 in 3x or in 3(x + 2).
  • A number that is ADDED, like the 3 in 3 + x, is a term. A term cannot be crossed out just because it appears on the top and on the bottom. (3 + x) / (3 + y) is not x / y.
  • To check, put in real numbers. If the two fractions have different values, the step was wrong. If it is a sum, take out a common factor first, as in 2x + 6 = 2(x + 3).

The rule: (k × a) / (k × b) = a / b, but (k + a) / (k + b) is not a / b

For parents: A very common slip is to cross out a number that is added, so that (a + b) / a becomes b. Try it with real numbers: a = 2 and b = 3 gives 5/2 on one side and 3 on the other. Ask your teen to find the numbers first and only then say whether the cancel is allowed. A good habit: if you cross something out, ask "does this multiply everything on the top?"

Check yourself

Can you cross out the 3s in (3 + x) / (3 + y) to get x / y?

Check yourself

What does (2x + 6) / 2 simplify to?

Check yourself

Which of these is a correct cancel?

Next lesson: Probability: a coin never owes you a tail → More lessons

← All visual lessons